The woman in the coffee shop had been staring at her laptop for twenty minutes without typing a word. Her lips moved slightly, eyebrows shifting through a range of micro-expressions—confusion, defiance, careful explanation. She was clearly deep in conversation, except she was completely alone. When she finally started typing, it was in a furious burst, like someone who’d finally figured out the perfect comeback.
I recognized the look. The mental rehearsal of a conversation that would probably never happen, or if it did, would go nothing like the script. The careful preparation for confrontations that exist only in our minds, where we get to be articulate and brave and say exactly what we mean. Where the other person finally understands, finally apologizes, finally sees us clearly.
This peculiar form of shadowboxing with imaginary opponents serves a purpose beyond simple anxiety or overthinking. The conversations we rehearse reveal the conversations we needed to have but couldn’t, the words we wished someone had said but didn’t, the protection we’re still providing for a younger version of ourselves who learned that being caught off-guard was dangerous.
1. You couldn’t predict which version of your parent you’d get
Growing up with emotional weather systems instead of predictable parents creates amateur meteorologists of mood. Sunny one moment, storming the next, with no barometric pressure to warn of incoming changes. These kids constantly scan for signs, preparing responses for every possible climate.
The rehearsals start young. If Mom comes home happy, you have one script. If she’s had a bad day, you need another. You practice both in your head on the school bus ride home, adding variations for tired-Mom, stressed-Mom, distracted-Mom. By adolescence, you’ve got entire decision trees mapped out, conversation flowcharts that account for every emotional permutation.
Adult rehearsers still run these programs, preparing for every possible version of every person they might encounter. They’ll practice asking for a raise with six different boss moods in mind, rehearse breaking plans with friends through every potential reaction. The exhausting mental labor of trying to stay one step ahead of unpredictability.
2. Your feelings were regularly invalidated or minimized
“You’re being too sensitive.” “That didn’t happen like that.” “You always exaggerate.” When children hear these phrases repeatedly, they learn to doubt their own perceptions. More importantly, they learn to pre-argue their case, gathering evidence before anyone has asked for it.
The mental rehearsals become closing arguments in cases that haven’t gone to trial. You practice explaining why you’re upset with footnotes and citations, preparing rebuttals to dismissals that haven’t happened yet. Every imagined conversation includes preemptive defenses: “I know you think I’m overreacting, but…” “Before you say I’m being dramatic…”
Watch someone who rehearses conversations and you’ll notice they often argue both sides. They’ll spend as much time voicing the dismissive responses as they do crafting their own words. They’re simultaneously prosecutor and defense attorney, judge and jury, building airtight cases for feelings that should need no justification.
3. Conflict was either explosive or completely forbidden
In some households, conflict operates like a light switch—flooding everything with harsh brightness or leaving everyone fumbling in the dark. No dimmer switch, no middle ground, no healthy disagreement that resolves into understanding.
Children from these homes rehearse conversations like bomb squad technicians. Every word choice matters. The wrong phrase could detonate everything or be smothered in suffocating silence. They practice threading impossible needles—expressing disagreement without triggering explosion, voicing needs without seeming demanding.
The rehearsals often include escape routes. “If they start yelling, I’ll say this and leave.” “If they give me the silent treatment, I’ll wait two days then send this text.” They’re not just practicing conversations; they’re choreographing entire contingency plans.
4. You were parentified or made responsible for others’ emotions
When children become emotional support animals for their own parents, therapists without training or consent, they learn their job includes managing adult feelings. Preventing meltdowns, maintaining family equilibrium. Their own emotions become secondary to household stability.
These rehearsers practice conversations that carefully account for everyone else’s potential feelings. They’ll run through scenarios where they need something, but spend most of the mental energy figuring out how to frame it so no one feels guilty, burdened, or upset. “I need to ask for help with tuition, but if I phrase it this way, Dad won’t feel like a failure…”
The mental preparation includes emotional care packages for others. They rehearse not just what they’ll say, but how they’ll comfort the person they’re talking to about the impact of their own needs. Apologizing for existing while simultaneously trying to advocate for themselves.
5. Your achievements were either ignored or turned into pressure
Growing up in a house where nothing was ever good enough, or where success immediately raised the bar impossibly higher, creates a particular kind of rehearsal pattern. Every conversation about accomplishments requires careful calibration.
These mental run-throughs involve complex equations: enough pride to seem confident but not arrogant, enough humility to avoid seeming boastful, enough gratitude to the right people, enough acknowledgment of luck and privilege. They practice sharing good news like defusing bombs, trying to find the exact tone that won’t trigger criticism or dismissal.
The skeptics are built right into their rehearsals. They voice the minimizations before anyone else can: “I know it’s not that big a deal, but…” “Other people have done more impressive things, but…” They’ve internalized their critics so thoroughly that they argue against themselves in their own imaginary conversations.
6. You learned early that love was conditional
Performance-based love creates performers, even in private mental spaces. Adults who had to earn childhood affection by being good, smart, helpful, or invisible rehearse conversations like auditions. Every interaction becomes a chance to prove worthiness.
The mental preparations include costume changes. They’ll practice the same conversation as competent-professional-them, vulnerable-but-not-too-needy-them, funny-charming-them. Each version carefully calibrated to maximize the chances of being seen as deserving of whatever they’re asking for—time, attention, basic human consideration.
Watch for the rehearsals that include proof of value. “I’ll mention the project I just finished before asking for vacation days.” “I’ll remind them of all the times I’ve helped before saying I need something.” They’re not just practicing words; they’re building cases for why they deserve to be heard.
7. Your boundaries were consistently violated
When boundaries get treated as suggestions rather than stop signs, children become lawyers for their own limits. They grow up preparing elaborate arguments for why they should be allowed to say no, have privacy, own their experiences.
These rehearsals often sound like Supreme Court arguments. They anticipate every challenge to their boundaries, prepare rebuttals to guilt trips, practice maintaining positions against emotional manipulation. “When she says I’m being selfish, I’ll respond with…” “If he threatens to be hurt by my boundary, I’ll remember that…”
The mental energy spent could power small cities. They’re not just practicing saying no; they’re preparing for the full theatrical production that saying no has historically required. The rehearsals include footnotes, appendices, and prepared statements for every possible guilt-inducing response.
8. You were never allowed to be imperfect
Perfection as a survival strategy creates rehearsers of the highest order. When mistakes meant withdrawal of love, criticism, or shame, children learn to practice every interaction until it’s flawless. They grow into adults who rehearse asking questions in meetings, practice leaving voicemails, prepare scripts for ordering coffee.
The mental run-throughs become recursive loops, practicing the practice. They’ll rehearse a conversation, then rehearse what to do if they forget their rehearsed lines. Backup plans for backup plans, all in service of never being caught unprepared, never stumbling, never revealing the human messiness that once felt so dangerous.
These patterns often include post-conversation rehearsals too. They’ll replay interactions that already happened, practicing what they should have said, preparing for the next time. The conversation never really ends; it just moves from future to past tense, equally imaginary in both directions.
Final thoughts
That woman in the coffee shop eventually closed her laptop, apparently having resolved whatever internal dialogue she’d been conducting. She looked satisfied, like someone who’d won an argument, even though she’d been alone the entire time. Maybe she had won something—the chance to say what needed saying, even if only to herself.
The conversations we rehearse are museums of our childhood experiences, carefully curated collections of the times we couldn’t speak, weren’t heard, or learned that words were weapons requiring careful handling. Each mental run-through is both symptom and attempted cure, problem and solution wrapped in one exhausting package.
The real question isn’t whether we rehearse these conversations—most of us do, to some degree. It’s whether we’re practicing for conversations that might actually help us heal, or just reinforcing the same protective patterns that kept us safe but small. Sometimes the bravest thing isn’t having the perfectly rehearsed conversation. It’s letting the conversation happen without a script, trusting that we can handle whatever comes, imperfect and unrehearsed and achingly real.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.